Current Trade-In Status - 12/5/2024: We have made some progress, but spaces for drop-off are filling quickly.
Please call the store BEFORE bringing boxes or bags. If we are low on space, we may ask you to wait.
Bear in mind, that the last 2 weeks  of December, we pause on taking in more material for end-of-year inventory.

Amish

Amish

  • Written in Love (An Amish Letters Novel) front cover by Kathleen Fuller, ISBN: 0310359929

    Written in Love (An Amish Letters Novel) [426059]

    Retail Price $7.99
    Firefly Price $3.50
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Good condition. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art. If you need images of this specific item, please contact us. Firefly SKU:...
    Retail Price $7.99
    Firefly Price $3.50
  • A Brighter Dawn: (A Dual-Time Amish Christian Fiction Book Set in Pre-WWII Germany and Present-Day Lancaster County) (Amish Memories) front cover by Leslie Gould, ISBN: 0764240242

    A Brighter Dawn: (A Dual-Time Amish Christian Fiction Book Set in Pre-WWII Germany and Present-Day Lancaster County) (Amish Memories) [424376]

    Retail Price $17.99
    Firefly Price $8.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Very Good condition. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art. If you need images of this specific item, please contact us. Firefly SKU:...
    Retail Price $17.99
    Firefly Price $8.99
  • This Passing Hour: (A Dual-Time Amish Christian Fiction Book Set in WWII and Present-Day Lancaster County) (Amish Memories) front cover by Leslie Gould, ISBN: 0764240250

    This Passing Hour: (A Dual-Time Amish Christian Fiction Book Set in WWII and Present-Day Lancaster County) (Amish Memories) [424375]

    Retail Price $16.99
    Firefly Price $8.50
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Very Good condition. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art. If you need images of this specific item, please contact us. Firefly SKU:...
    Retail Price $16.99
    Firefly Price $8.50
  • Love Blooms at the Apple Blossom Inn front cover by Tracy Fredrychowski, ISBN: 1734241152

    Love Blooms at the Apple Blossom Inn [424374]

    Retail Price $12.99
    Firefly Price $6.50
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Very Good condition. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art. If you need images of this specific item, please contact us. Firefly SKU:...
    Retail Price $12.99
    Firefly Price $6.50
  • On Her Own 2 Brides of Webster County front cover by Wanda E. Brunstetter, ISBN: 1597896101

    On Her Own 2 Brides of Webster County [424371]

    Retail Price $12.95
    Firefly Price $6.50
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Very Good condition. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art. If you need images of this specific item, please contact us. Firefly SKU:...
    Retail Price $12.95
    Firefly Price $6.50
  • A Cousin's Prayer 2 Indiana Cousins front cover by Wanda E. Brunstetter, ISBN: 1624162258

    A Cousin's Prayer 2 Indiana Cousins [424368]

    Retail Price $9.99
    Firefly Price $4.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Good condition. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art. If you need images of this specific item, please contact us. Firefly SKU:...
    Retail Price $9.99
    Firefly Price $4.99
  • Faithful to Laura (A Middlefield Family Novel) front cover by Kathleen Fuller, ISBN: 071808277X

    Faithful to Laura (A Middlefield Family Novel) [424206]

    Retail Price $16.99
    Firefly Price $3.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Very Good condition. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art. If you need images of this specific item, please contact us. Firefly SKU:...
    Retail Price $16.99
    Firefly Price $3.99
  • Amish White Christmas Pie front cover by Wanda E. Brunstetter, ISBN: 1616268662

    Amish White Christmas Pie [424205]

    Retail Price $14.99
    Firefly Price $7.50
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Very Good condition. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art. If you need images of this specific item, please contact us. Firefly SKU:...
    Retail Price $14.99
    Firefly Price $7.50
  • Hannah's Dream front cover by Jerry Eicher, ISBN: 0978798732

    Hannah's Dream [422759]

    Retail Price $9.99
    Firefly Price $4.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Very Good condition. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art. If you need images of this specific item, please contact us. Firefly SKU:...
    Retail Price $9.99
    Firefly Price $4.99
  • A Blessing for Miriam 2 Land of Promise front cover by Jerry S. Eicher, ISBN: 0736958819

    A Blessing for Miriam 2 Land of Promise [419661]

    Retail Price $13.99
    Firefly Price $6.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Good condition. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art. If you need images of this specific item, please contact us. Firefly SKU:...
    Retail Price $13.99
    Firefly Price $6.99
  • Miriam's Secret 1 Land of Promise front cover by Jerry S. Eicher, ISBN: 0736958797

    Miriam's Secret 1 Land of Promise [419660]

    Retail Price $13.99
    Firefly Price $6.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Good condition. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art. If you need images of this specific item, please contact us. Firefly SKU:...
    Retail Price $13.99
    Firefly Price $6.99
  • Love Finds You in Sugarcreek, Ohio front cover by Serena B. Miller, ISBN: 1609360028

    Love Finds You in Sugarcreek, Ohio [419658]

    Retail Price $12.99
    Firefly Price $5.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Good condition. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art. If you need images of this specific item, please contact us. Firefly SKU:...
    Retail Price $12.99
    Firefly Price $5.99
  • The Harvest of Grace 3 Ada's House front cover by Cindy Woodsmall, ISBN: 1400073987

    The Harvest of Grace 3 Ada's House [419652]

    Retail Price $13.99
    Firefly Price $6.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Good condition. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art. If you need images of this specific item, please contact us. Firefly SKU:...
    Retail Price $13.99
    Firefly Price $6.99
  • Stitches in Time 2 The Deacon's Family front cover by Fisher, ISBN: 0800727525

    Stitches in Time 2 The Deacon's Family [419649]

    Retail Price $15.99
    Firefly Price $7.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Very Good condition. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art. If you need images of this specific item, please contact us. Firefly SKU:...
    Retail Price $15.99
    Firefly Price $7.99
  • Susanna's Dream: The Lost Sisters of Pleasant Valley, Book Two front cover by Marta Perry, ISBN: 0425253759

    Susanna's Dream: The Lost Sisters of Pleasant Valley, Book Two [419648]

    Retail Price $15.00
    Firefly Price $7.50
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Very Good condition. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art. If you need images of this specific item, please contact us. Firefly SKU:...
    Retail Price $15.00
    Firefly Price $7.50
  • Beloved Hope 2 Heart of the Frontier front cover by Tracie Peterson, ISBN: 0764213288

    Beloved Hope 2 Heart of the Frontier [419646]

    Retail Price $16.00
    Firefly Price $7.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Good condition. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art. If you need images of this specific item, please contact us. Firefly SKU:...
    Retail Price $16.00
    Firefly Price $7.99
  • Treasured Grace 1 Heart of the Frontier front cover by Tracie Peterson, ISBN: 076421327X

    Treasured Grace 1 Heart of the Frontier [419645]

    Retail Price $16.00
    Firefly Price $7.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Very Good condition. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art. If you need images of this specific item, please contact us. Firefly SKU:...
    Retail Price $16.00
    Firefly Price $7.99
  • Love Finds You in Paradise, Pennsylvania front cover by Loree Lough, ISBN: 1934770663

    Love Finds You in Paradise, Pennsylvania [419644]

    Retail Price $12.99
    Firefly Price $6.50
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Very Good condition. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art. If you need images of this specific item, please contact us. Firefly SKU:...
    Retail Price $12.99
    Firefly Price $6.50
  • The Devoted 3 The Bishop's Family front cover by Suzanne Woods Fisher, ISBN: 0800723228

    The Devoted 3 The Bishop's Family [419640]

    Retail Price $16.00
    Firefly Price $7.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Good condition. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art. If you need images of this specific item, please contact us. Firefly SKU:...
    Retail Price $16.00
    Firefly Price $7.99
  • The Quieting 2 Bishop's Family front cover by Suzanne Woods Fisher, ISBN: 080072321X

    The Quieting 2 Bishop's Family [419639]

    Retail Price $14.99
    Firefly Price $7.50
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Good condition. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art. If you need images of this specific item, please contact us. Firefly SKU:...
    Retail Price $14.99
    Firefly Price $7.50