Starting July 2026, we are now requiring appointments for dropping off any material being brought in for trade credit or possible cash purchase.
This new system replaces our previous waiting list. We will no longer be scheduling quarterly trade-in hiatuses.

Please call the store for additional information and to schedule a drop-off appointment. Donations without needing credit do not require an appointment.

Puzzles

Puzzles

  • Pantone Rainbow 1000-Piece Puzzle front cover, ISBN: 1797243195

    Pantone Rainbow 1000-Piece Puzzle

    Firefly Price $21.95
    This item is New and unaltered from when published.Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art. If you need images of this...
    Firefly Price $21.95
  • The Old Produce Stand 500 Piece Puzzle [533234]

    The Old Produce Stand 500 Piece Puzzle [533234]

    Firefly Price $6.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Good condition. Complete in box, intact. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art...
    Firefly Price $6.99
  • Fall Finds 500 Piece Puzzle [533233]

    Fall Finds 500 Piece Puzzle [533233]

    Firefly Price $6.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Good condition. Complete in box, intact. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art...
    Firefly Price $6.99
  • Lilac Point Glen 500 Piece Puzzle [533232]

    Lilac Point Glen 500 Piece Puzzle [533232]

    Retail Price $12.99
    Firefly Price $6.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Good condition. Complete in box, intact. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art...
    Retail Price $12.99
    Firefly Price $6.99
  • Fox Hill Farms 300-Piece Jigsaw Puzzle [533231]

    Fox Hill Farms 300-Piece Jigsaw Puzzle [533231]

    Firefly Price $6.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Very Good condition. Complete in box, intact. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or...
    Firefly Price $6.99
  • Wooden Animal Puzzles for Toddlers [532636]

    Wooden Animal Puzzles for Toddlers [532636]

    Retail Price $15.99
    Firefly Price $11.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Very Good condition. Complete in box, intact. This item cannot be shipped as Media Mail and may require additional shipping costs. Individual puzzles are...
    Retail Price $15.99
    Firefly Price $11.99
  • Seaside Hill 1000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle [531555]

    Seaside Hill 1000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle [531555]

    Retail Price $12.99
    Firefly Price $6.50
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Very Good condition. Complete in box, intact. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or...
    Retail Price $12.99
    Firefly Price $6.50
  • Citrus 1000 Piece Puzzle [531553]

    Citrus 1000 Piece Puzzle [531553]

    Firefly Price $8.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Very Good condition. Complete in box, intact. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or...
    Firefly Price $8.99
  • Coastal Lighthouses, Seaside Beach 1000 Piece Puzzle [531552]

    Coastal Lighthouses, Seaside Beach 1000 Piece Puzzle [531552]

    Retail Price $16.99
    Firefly Price $8.50
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Very Good condition. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art. If you need images...
    Retail Price $16.99
    Firefly Price $8.50
  • Country Gardens 300 Large Piece Puzzle [531523]

    Country Gardens 300 Large Piece Puzzle [531523]

    Retail Price $12.99
    Firefly Price $5.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Good condition. Complete in box, intact. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art...
    Retail Price $12.99
    Firefly Price $5.99
  • London (Travel Diary) 500 Piece Puzzle [531522]

    London (Travel Diary) 500 Piece Puzzle [531522]

    Retail Price $16.99
    Firefly Price $6.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Good condition. Complete in box, intact. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art...
    Retail Price $16.99
    Firefly Price $6.99
  • Jolly Hill Farms 500 Piece Puzzle [531521]

    Jolly Hill Farms 500 Piece Puzzle [531521]

    Retail Price $11.00
    Firefly Price $5.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Good condition. Complete in box, intact. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art...
    Retail Price $11.00
    Firefly Price $5.99
  • Cooper's Corner 500 Piece EZ Grip Puzzle [531520]

    Cooper's Corner 500 Piece EZ Grip Puzzle [531520]

    Retail Price $16.99
    Firefly Price $6.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Very Good condition. Complete in box, intact. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or...
    Retail Price $16.99
    Firefly Price $6.99
  • Coast of Italy 1000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle front cover, ISBN: 0735384835

    Coast of Italy 1000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle [530480]

    Retail Price $19.99
    Firefly Price $9.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Very Good condition. Complete in box, intact. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or...
    Retail Price $19.99
    Firefly Price $9.99
  • Art Stamps 1000 Piece Puzzle [530426]

    Art Stamps 1000 Piece Puzzle [530426]

    Firefly Price $6.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Good condition. Complete in box, intact. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or cover art...
    Firefly Price $6.99
  • Kitten and Yarn 100 Piece Puzzle [530266]

    Kitten and Yarn 100 Piece Puzzle [530266]

    Firefly Price $3.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Very Good condition. Complete in box, intact. Cover image may be sourced as stock images from OpenLibrary.org and may not represent the actual item or...
    Firefly Price $3.99
  • Foul Play & Cabernet Classic Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle  [530264]

    Foul Play & Cabernet Classic Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle [530264]

    Retail Price $19.99
    Firefly Price $9.99
    This item is Used and is listed as being in Very Good condition. Complete in box, intact. Includes booklet, bagged puzzle. Box has edge and corner wear, but clean and intact. Cover image may be...
    Retail Price $19.99
    Firefly Price $9.99